Best NY Sports Betting Sites: Top New York Sportsbooks September 2023

The New York Post ranks the best legal New York Sports Betting Sites available to bettors in the Empire State in September 2023, and the best sports betting bonuses available in NYC.

• Please note: BetMGM new customer offer is not currently available in New York.

Latest New York sports betting news

There is breaking news in the new gambling capital of the United States. Senator Joe Addabbo has filed a bill that would increase the number of operators permitted in the state of New York.

If it passes, the number of operators will be increased to 14 by January of 2024. However, the number would then increase again to 16 by January of 2025.

NY Online Sportsbook of the Week

Caesars Sportsbook is easily one of the leading online sports betting sites available to NY sports bettors. They boast an excellent range of sports markets, including live betting, futures and same-game parlay markets, as well as en excellent welcome offer.

Their range of odds, as well as their promotions for existing customers are superb, are just a few more factors that make them a sportsbook that’s well worth your time.

September has arrived and that means the sports calendar is about to be filled as football is back.

While everyone is eagerly anticipating the start of the NFL regular season and College Football, there is still plenty of MLB action to tune into.

The MLB playoff race is heating up, as contending teams will enter the home stretch and make their final push for the postseason.

On top of all that, the UFC will be a mainstay as they have UFC 293 set for September 9. They’ll also have Fight Night cards on every other Saturday of the month.

Major Sporting Events in September 2023

Key NY Online Sports Betting Regulations

In order to wager your money on sports and withdraw any winnings in New York, you must be at least 21 years old, as well as being within New York state lines.

Bettors will only be allowed to place bets at one of the eight legal and licensed online sportsbooks as outlined in the table below. Any online sportsbook not on our list, is not legal to play on.

Our Top Sports Betting Sites in New York

1. PointsBet Sportsbook

With a simple and efficient online site, PointsBet is still a popular choice among bettors. With an exciting new customer offer, PointsBet is a good place to start for new bettors in New York. 

PointsBet offers similar markets to the big names in online sports betting, their odds are strong, and their latest welcome bonus is one of the best in the business.

Their simplicity is one of their main attractions, and it is very easy to use, but if you’re looking for a better all-around experience in online sports betting, PointsBet isn’t the place to start.

2. FanDuel Sportsbook

FanDuel started in the fantasy sports arena, but have quickly established themselves as one of the most popular online sports betting sites in every state in which they’ve gone live.

The range of markets they have on offers, including pre-match, live betting and futures options stand out from the competition. Their parlay betting section is also one of the best around, particularly for same-game parlays, which are surging in popularity worldwide.

FanDuel Sportsbook also rewards repeat players with some of the best existing customer specials you’ll find. Notable for both their generosity in how simple to understand and redeem they are.

3. BetMGM

BetMGM Sportsbook is a great place to bet and new customers can unlock up to $1,500 in bonus bets just by signing up!

Both desktop and mobile sites are very impressive, simple to use and easy to understand. BetMGM also boasts a fantastic mobile app, allowing users to wager on the go, wherever you are.

They provide a strong range of sports to bet on with the variety of markets you’ll find as good as any US online sportsbook. Like FanDuel they have some strong offers to keep existing customers coming back to their site too.

*This offer is not available in NY, DC, NV, or KS.

4. Caesars Sportsbook

The Caesars brand took over the William Hill online sportsbook in 2021 and it’s gone from strength to strength since then adding plenty of glitz and glamour to a big offering of sports and markets.

Caesar spoils you arguably the most eye-catching promos for new and existing customers of any US sports betting site. Their choice of deposit and withdrawal options is also unparalleled, testament to the inclusive feel they promote.

Finally, they also excel in providing for New York’s mobile players with a fantastic mobile app and easy to use mobile site.

5. BetRivers

Initially operating as an online casino, BetRivers has impressively launched its own online sportsbook, and provides a fantastic experience for bettors in New York. 

Their welcome offer is strong, with similar offers available with other sportsbooks. BetRivers’ strengths come in their mobile app, which is one of the best in the sports betting industry, with live streaming and in-play wagering available.

Despite only launching as a Sportsbook in 2020, BetRivers is still a safe option, and proves to be a good choice for new bettors. 

BallyBet

The newest member on the New York Sports betting scene, BallyBet arrives with a wealth of knowledge in sports betting. Despite the small footprint of the online betting site, BallyBet extend to 16 states, showing its popularity and ability to expand throughout the USA.

There may be some time before BallyBet is competing with the big boys already in the Empire State, but with a whole host of promotions and bonuses, it’s likely that NYC bettors get to liking using Bally Bet.

NY Sports Betting Sites Features

In-Play Betting

In-Play betting involves wagering on an an event after it has started, and up until its conclusion. For example, if you placed a bet on the Giants to win at halftime of their game, this would be an in-play bet. 

Live-Streaming

The live streaming feature allows bettors to watch the game they are betting on. On the online sportsbook site, the game will be shown while you make your selections for in-play bets. 

Parlay Betting

A parlay bet combines two or more wagers into one bet, and the bet is dependent on all of the individual wagers winning. The benefit of this is that the total payout of the parlay is higher than individual bets on all legs of the parlay.

For example, you can combine the moneyline wager of the Giants, Jets and Yankees, and get a higher payout than if you put three single wagers on all three teams to win the moneyline. 

Same Game Parlay

A relatively new feature, but a same game parlay allows you to combine multiple bets from the same game into one bet.

For example, you could combine Saquon Barkley to score a touchdown, Giants to cover the spread and Over the total points into one wager. All of the legs in the same game parlay must win in order to payout. 

What are the benefits of betting online in New York?

Convenience – Online Betting can be done from anywhere

Promos and Bonuses –

Variety –

Best Odds – Regularly updated and consistently checked

Live Streaming – Free live sports with the best sportsbooks 

Payment Choices – Safety and security when wagering online

Convenience

Online sports betting in New York has never been easier. It’s as easy as pulling your mobile phone out of your pocket, opening up your laptop or loading up a tablet. 

For many people, travelling to your nearest sportsbook is not convenient at all. The legalization of sports betting in NY will make it far easier for them to place wagers when they want.

Promos and Bonuses 

One of the main attractions of online sports betting are the fantastic bonuses and promotions. New customer offers from online sportsbooks offer the potential to earn thousands of dollars worth of bonus cash and bonus bets.

The most lucrative opportunities come through new customer offers and welcome bonuses and you’re not limited to one sportsbook, allowing you to take advantage of welcome bonuses for as many sites as you choose.

Variety 

The best selection and extensive list of sports you can bet on is levels ahead with online sports betting. This allows you to bet all in one place, and all on the same site.

What comes with a long list of sports, is a huge variety of markets and props. You’ll find more types of bets online than you will at a retail sportsbook, and you’ll also be able to bet live on sports games. 

Best Odds 

Different sportsbooks will often have different odds on certain markets and game lines, so it is easy to check between different sportsbooks to see where you’re getting the most bang for your buck.

Live Streaming 

A mainstream feature in the best online sportsbooks nowadays, live streaming is available for certain games. You’re able to watch games not available through your regular cable television, whilst being able to bet live at the same time. 

Not all online sportsbooks have this feature, so it is worth checking out our table of features to check which sportsbooks offer live streaming.

Payment Choices 

Unlike retail sportsbooks which generally operate with cash, online sports betting sites allow players to deposit and withdraw through a massive variety of payment methods. 

Current widely available payment methods: 

• Debit Card
• Credit Card
• PayPal
• E-Check
• Skrill 
• Pay+
• Neteller
• Plus additional others

Many sportsbooks are opening up into accepting cryptocurrencies, so players can use their crypto funds to fund their betting accounts. 

New York Sports Betting Sign-Up Offers

Second Chance Bets

This is a great way to attract customers to New York Sportsbooks. Many operators use this as a sign-up bonus, and its attraction is that it guarantees a non-losing start to your relationship with an operator. If your first bet wins, you get your winnings; and if it loses, you get your money back as credits to carry on wagering.

Odds Boosts

Odds boosts tend to be used as a way of enticing existing sports betting customers to enjoy a wager. Look out for special offers from New York Betting Sites that mean your winnings on a particular event will be increased from the earlier price.

First Deposit Bonuses

This is another method whereby New York Online sportsbooks make their welcome for new customers even warmer. In this case, the amount you deposit in your new account is boosted by up to 100 per cent. That gives you some serious extra wagering power, and a wholesome amount of bonus bets to use.

Legal vs Offshore Betting Sites in New York

Legal sports betting sites are sports betting sites that allow players to legally place bets on any sports market they have to offer, as long as they’re legally licensed in your state. 

Traditionally some players have seen offshore betting sites as an alternative to legal sports betting sites. These are often used by players in states where sports betting is not yet legal.

A number of the most well known offshore betting sites are located in the likes of Curacao, the Isle of Man, Malta and Costa Rica, with these being some of those sites listed below. 

• BetOnline
• XBet
• Bovada
• MyBookie
• BetUS
• SportsBetting

In regards to sports betting in New York, there are no legal offshore betting sites, with a number of states now offering legal and licensed sportsbooks for people to bet with to avoid players running into the issues that offshore betting sites provide.

Offshore betting poses a number of risks and issues for those that choose to bet with offshore betting sites. These issues include:

• Lack of US Licensing means no protection from player mistreatment
• Money not protected if sportsbook goes bust
• Potential Money Laundering

Using legal sports betting sites allow players to avoid these risks as they need to follow state rules and regulations in order to operate legally.

Retail Sportsbooks in New York

There have been a number of retail sportsbooks in New York since 2013, after the NY Gaming Economic Development act.

Whilst retail sportsbooks still provide a fun and entertaining experience for bettors, online sports betting allows for more convenience, and provides better offers and promotions for customers which you would not get at a retail sportsbook. 

What New Yorksports teams can I bet on?

New York Jets

One half of New York’s Football scene, the Jets have won just one Super Bowl in their time as a franchise.

You can bet on all the Jets regular season games, as well as whether or not they’ll make the playoffs or even win the Super Bowl. 

New York Giants

The NFC franchise in New York has been far more successful traditionally, with the Giants winning four Super Bowls, including two in the last 15 years. 

Each of the Giants regular season games are available to bet on, as well as betting on the total number of wins they earn, and whether or not the Giants will win the Super Bowl. 

New York Knicks

Based in Manhattan, the Knicks have won two NBA Championships, and are one of only two NBA teams to be located in their original city. 

Markets available to bet on the Knicks are all of their regular season games, whether they’ll win the Eastern Conference and reach the NBA Finals. 

Brooklyn Nets

The Nets have made the NBA finals twice in their history in 2002 and 2003, with Brooklyn — then located in New Jersey — losing these to the Lakers and Spurs respectively.

You can bet on the Nets to win the NBA title, Eastern Conference and reach the NBA finals, with all of their regular season games also available to be wagered on as well.

New York Yankees

The Yankees are America’s most successful baseball team, with an amazing history totalling 27 world series titles. Their most recent title came in 2009, so it has been somewhat of a drought for Yankee fans. 

Bettors can wager on every Yankees’ regular season game, as well as whether or not New York will make the playoffs or win the World Series.

New York City FC

New York’s newest sports franchise, NYCFC play in MLS and are the current MLS Champions. Playing their first game in just 2015, no team has won the MLS Cup in a shorter period of time than NYCFC. 

You are able to wager on all of New York City FC’s regular season games, as well as whether or not they’ll make the playoffs, or win the MLS Cup.

New York online sports betting FAQs

Is online sports betting legit?

Online sports betting is completely legal and legitimate when you play with a site that’s officially licensed in New York where you are depositing, betting or withdrawing.

Your money is safe with a licensed sportsbook and with excellent customer service facilities available, there is plenty of help available should you need it. Thus far, there are a handful of legal New York Sports betting sites available to bettors in the Empire State.

Is online sports betting legal in New York?

Yes. Online sports betting was approved by the state legislature in April 2021. The first wave of licensed sites went live just before Super Bowl 56, and there are currently six sportsbooks live in New York.

The New York Gaming Commission approved nine licenses to sportsbooks to operate online in November 2021, and online sports betting has been live since January 2022 in New York.

How do I bet online in New York?

Bettors in New York able to bet online legally via any of the sportsbooks licensed to operate in New York, all of which are mentioned in this piece.

All NY licensed sportsbooks are accessible via their websites. Some also have mobile betting apps for iOS and Android devices, allowing you to play via your mobile device.

As long as you are over the age of 21 and within New York state lines you are able to wager and bet with any of the licensed sportsbooks in NY.

What sports can I bet online in NY? 

The first wave of Empire State sports betting sites cater for betting on all the major leagues of US Sport: NFL football, MLB baseball, NBA basketball, NHL hockey and MLS soccer as well as college sports and numerous other leagues and sports around the world.

The top online sportsbooks tend to have the most diverse ranges of sports and odds on offer with everything from UFC, boxing, tennis and NASCAR to darts, rugby, badminton and more.

Can I bet on College Sports in New York? 

Yes. It’s legal to bet on college sports matchups as long as they don’t involve teams from the state of New York and aren’t being played in the state of New York.

Unfortunately, for bettors in New York it is illegal to wager on any New York college sports teams, even if they’re playing on the road. This is very similar to the law in New Jersey.

You can still bet on March Madness and College Football bowl games legally.