Anytime Touchdown Scorer Predictions

We missed out on paydirt during Thursday Night Football but we have several more anytime and first touchdown scorer predictions for Sunday's full slate as we continue looking to get the best of the NFL odds.

We went just 2-for-5 with our picks in Week 1, but the beauty of this market is that still led to a +7.5-unit profit. Thanks go to Kansas City Chiefs rookie Rashee Rice's first career touchdown on Thursday Night Football, and Washington Commanders running back Brian Robinson Jr. scoring the first touchdown of his team's game on Sunday afternoon.

We endured a rough go on Thursday Night Football to start our Week 2 touchdown scorer predictions, missing on Boston Scott in this column and on Dallas Goedert via . But it takes just one (or two) hits to make for a profitable week in this market, so we're getting right at it!

Here are our best NFL anytime and first touchdown scorer predictions to boost your NFL Week 2 predictions and player props (odds via our best NFL betting sites; pick confidence based on a 1-to-5-star scale).

Anytime touchdown scorer predictions

Dolphins vs. Patriots anytime touchdown scorer prediction: Rhamondre Stevenson, Patriots, RB 2+ touchdowns (+850 via FanDuel)

Even with Ezekiel Elliott making his New England Patriots debut, incumbent workhorse Rhamondre Stevenson led the backfield while drawing 73% of the snaps played last week. Though he finished with 12 carries for just 25 yards, Stevenson hauled in all six of his targets for an extra 64 yards against the Philadelphia Eagles.

It's that dual-usage I like for this two-plus touchdowns bet with New England a 2.5-point home underdog against the Miami Dolphins. Miami ranks last in the NFL in run-stop win rate through just one week and gave up three rushing touchdowns during a Week 1 upset win over the Los Angeles Chargers. It's easy to see why our Neil Parker likes Stevenson's yardage total with his NFL Week 2 player props.

Stevenson's highest odds to score an anytime touchdown on Sunday Night Football are just +130 via Caesars. Let's shoot higher with these +850 odds from FanDuel for two-plus scores. BetMGM is offering this same prop at +400.

Bet $5, Get $200 in Bonus Bets

Bears vs. Buccaneers anytime touchdown scorer prediction: Khalil Herbert, Bears, RB (+240 via DraftKings)

The Tampa Bay Buccaneers pulled off an upset of the Minnesota Vikings in Week 1, but they gave up a receiving touchdown to running back Alexander Mattison along the way. They also checked in at a middling 16th in run-stop win rate.

While the Bucs are suddenly 3-point favorites by the NFL's Week 2 odds, they were 1.5-point underdogs in the opening NFL odds. That should offer some hope for a Chicago Bears team that the rival Green Bay Packers trounced in Week 1.

The Bears balanced their backfield work during that loss. Khalil Herbert played 36% of the snaps and registered nine carries to go with three receptions on five targets as the veteran of the group. While it was rookie teammate Roschon Johnson who found the end zone on one of his five carries, Week 2 projections still favor Herbert to receive more touches, and he's getting the highest probability of finding paydirt among Bears running backs.

DraftKings' +240 odds is the best price, with Caesars hanging odds of just +175.

Bet $5, Get $200 in Bonus Bets

Vikings vs. Eagles anytime touchdown scorer prediction: Boston Scott, Eagles, RB (+350 via FanDuel) ✖️

All eyes (and bets) are on Eagles running back D'Andre Swift to handle the bulk of the backfield work with Kenneth Gainwell ruled out of Thursday Night Football. However, Swift's odds in the anytime touchdown market come at a high of +160 via FanDuel. I don't hate it in a game the Eagles are set as 7-point favorites with an implied team total of 28 points, but the value is much better on the sixth-year rusher, Scott, via this number from FanDuel.

Gainwell led the Eagles with 14 carries in last week's win over the New England Patriots. QB Jalen Hurts had nine rushing attempts and Scott and Swift each received just a single tote. Yet, Swift's priced at +160 for an anytime touchdown and Rashaad Penny, who spent last week inactive, is even being given a better chance of finding the end zone in Week 2 with odds as high as +275 via BetMGM.

Projections for Thursday night have Swift with 0.3 touchdowns while Penny and Scott are both projected for 0.2 TDs. Yet, Scott's being priced well above his teammates despite being in head coach Nick Sirianni's system for longer and scoring 10 rushing touchdowns in the last two years. We need to take advantage of these higher odds on the less popular player.

Not intended for use in MA
Affiliate Disclosure: Sportsbook Review may receive advertising commissions for visits to a sportsbook

First touchdown scorer predictions

Raiders vs. Bills first touchdown scorer prediction: Josh Allen, Bills, QB (+750 via DraftKings)

Sometimes with the touchdown market you have to play the motivation angle.

The first stop on that bus this week is Buffalo Bills QB Josh Allen. Annually an MVP hopeful, the sixth-year starter began his 2023 campaign with three interceptions in the Bills' shocking Week 1 loss to the New York Jets in a game which Aaron Rodgers departed early in the first quarter. But the Jets have long had his number, that game was on the road, and the weather was lousy.

I'm looking for Allen to show a bit of ego in the Bills' home opener and to lean on his legs early in a game the Bills are set as 8.5-point favorites.

Allen's also the second-shortest favorite on the board in this market for Raiders vs. Bills but with odds of +750 via DraftKings with a low price of +550 via Caesars.

Kentucky bettors: Sports betting is coming soon!

Kentucky sports betting will launch Sept. 28 so get pre-launch offers before it's too late!Don't miss out on Kentucky sportsbook promos or the best Kentucky sports betting apps!

21+ and present in KY. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER

NFL betting odds pages

(21+. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER)
* Bonuses not applicable in Ontario.